Skip to main content

The Honest Truth, from Dismal Scientists

Too long ago, Stephen Marglin wrote a book about economics titled, "The Dismal Science".  Even though it was a beautifully written book, I have always taken perverse comfort in the title.  My perverse comfort has something to do with the fact that economics has always captivated my mind  in the same way rhubarb has.  It hasn't. 

But the book is not the point, here.  It is this:  we easily delude ourselves about economics.  For instance, the notion that tax cuts will increase government revenue is a wildly popular political theme.  As soon as little Republican tots are weaned from their mother's milk, they are fed the notion that cutting taxes will somehow, magically, actually increase government revenue.  Little Republican tots first words are, "Ronald Reagan proved that!"

Almost every economist, whatever his or her political preference, agrees that, as Joel Slemord puts it, "Tax cuts don't pay for themselves!  Period!"

(Edward Lotterman, in an article in the St. Paul Pioneer Press, details the delusion.  He displays a litany of leading economists to make the point.  He includes a series of economic advisors to Republican Presidents, including Reagan and Bush.)

What does happen is this: 
     1)  Lowering taxes obviously decreases government income.
     2)  Lower tax rates do stimulate economic activity.
     3)  But, "No thoughtful person believes that this possible offset more than compensates for the first effect of these tax cuts.  Not a single one."

When Ronald Reagan cut taxes, he also closed tax loopholes, which did increase government income.  He created a larger tax base.  And, for that reason, government income at the end of his tenure was higher than when he began.  But if he had not cut taxes, the income would have been even higher.

What this means today is that if we cut the tax rate, the deficit will balloon, not shrink. 

But try to tell that to a Tea Bagger, or almost any Republican politician!  Joel Slemrod, who headed the Council of Economic Advisors under George W. Bush, says, "cranks and charlatans" sold this idea to the American people.  Martin Feldstein, who headed the CEA under Reagan, agrees that tax cuts will not pay for themselves. 

If you aren't going to raise government income to pay for government expenditures, you have to cut the hell out of something:  the military, school systems, fire and police departments, quit making flu vaccines, eliminate Social Security, refuse to provide health care, stop repairing bridges and roads, sell the national parks to Continental Coal Company, or maybe ask health insurance companies to give us back our money. 

There isn't a magic way to provide services.  They have to be paid for. 

Of course fraud, waste, and mismanagement should be fought against!  All of it put together won't pay for the war in Iraq.  That was a waste!  And it was a fraud, and mismanaged, too.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Friends-- My step-father of 35 years died this morning. His name was Conrad Royksund. He was 86 years old. He was born into poverty on a farm near Puyallup, WA. He was the first member of his family to attend college and earned a PhD from the University of Chicago. He paid his way through all of that by fishing in Alaska. He spent his professional career as a college professor. I met him when I was just 3 years old and don't actually have any memories of my life befor e he was in it. He was intimidatingly smart, funny as hell, and worked his ass off. He taught me to meet people with kindness and decency until I was certain they could not be trusted. He taught me to meet ideas with carving knives until I was certain they could. I will remember him as one of the bravest, most curious, and funniest people I have ever met. He left this world with a satisfied mind. We are so grateful. Dan Hubbard

The Sea is Rising

Let us just step back:  two hundred and fifty years ago, or so, the ships of England and Spain had drifted onto a whole new continent, as they saw it, from far north to a savagely cold south; pole to pole, as if there were such things. Millions of people already lived here, some of them still hunters and gatherers; some of them very wealthy, indeed!  Gold and silver stolen from the southern Americas funded Spanish and English dreams. There was land, lots of land, under starry skies above, rich land, and oil and coal and iron ore.  The whole western world learned how to build industries not on simple muscle power, but on steam and oil.  We farmed, too, of course.  All we needed was cheap labor--slave labor from Africa, mostly, so the ships came with slave labor.  Chinese labor built railroad beds where there had been rock cliffs. Europeans, long used to killing each other for good, religious reasons, brought their religious savagery with them. ...

AT YEAR'S END, 2014

Ah!  There you are!  And so are we! After more than thirty years, sometimes Mari and I look at each other and say how surprising it is that we have found each other.  It often happens when we have decided that neither one of us wants to go adventuring: you know, to the grocery, or to a movie; or least of all, to a party designed to disguise gravity, deny arthritis, and display bottomless good humor. At the same time, sometimes Mari and I look at each other and say how surprising is everything that has happened to us.  The world we grew up in has gone, and now there is another, and that we are still here, as we were, and altogether new. It is Jao we are thinking of. This year, more than any other in our lives, has been the year when a grandchild has occupied a significant portion of our ordinary lives.  We have, in our various ways, come to have several grandchildren, but this time one of them has lived so nearby that we could walk to where he...